Games similar to Call of the Elder Gods

Enjoyed Call of the Elder Gods and looking for something fun to play next?

Our thinky games database has lots of hand-curated, detailed information about every game, so we're able to make great recommendations for other games you might enjoy. This includes other first-person, puzzle, and adventure games, more titles from Out of the Blue Games, and other games with narrative.

Take a look at some of the most similar games below.

Call of the Sea
Discover arcane knowledge on a remote South Pacific island.
Quern - Undying Thoughts
Uncover the secrets of Quern, solving contraption puzzles in this first-person puzzle adventure.
Mystery of the Malign
Untangle the threads behind a murder attempt at an eerie museum.
The 7th Guest (2026)
Solve the puzzles and riddles of a devious toymaker to uncover his dreadful machinations.
Dear Lighthouse
Repair sabotaged machinery on a remote, eerie island.
The Séance of Blake Manor
Investigate the disappearance of an aspirant occultist in a sinister hotel.
Return of the Obra Dinn
A grisly detective mystery aboard a ghost, merchant ship.
Dimhaven - The Lost Source
Camera in hand, uncover the mysteries of Dimhaven island through first-person adventure puzzles.
We Were Here Tomorrow
Solve asymmetrical puzzles with a friend inside a futuristic facility.
Outer Wilds
Explore a solar system and unravel its mysteries.
Causal Loop
Duplicate yourself to manipulate ancient alien systems.
Portal 2
Portal returns with an expansive story, new mechanics, and a co-op mode.
Myst (2021)
A genre-defining adventure across enigmatic worlds.
We Were Here
Solve co-op puzzles in an abandoned castle with only walkie-talkies to communicate.
Once Glorious Artahk
Solve murals and mysteries among the ruins of a bygone city.
Blue Prince
Search for Room 46 in a mysterious manor where the rooms are different each time you enter.
Spider and Web
Retrace the actions of a captured spy to a menacing interrogator.
Obduction
Explore a broken alien landscape in this first-person adventure from the creators of Myst.
Tri: Of Friendship and Madness
Conjure gravity-defying triangular platforms to explore every corner of the Odd Gods' world.
Creaks
Descend through the cracks in your walls to a world of avian folk and furniture monsters.
We Were Here Forever
You awaken, trapped within Castle Rock, to continue the co-op saga of the We Were Here series.
Year Walk
Follow an eerie Swedish folk ritual to catch a glimpse of the future.
The Talos Principle 2: Road to Elysium
A 3-part DLC that expands on the story of The Talos Principle 2 and offers extra challenging puzzles.
Hadean Lands
Learn rituals as an apprentice alchemist in a grand text-based adventure.
The House of Da Vinci 2
Solve all kinds of puzzle boxes throughout a Renaissance adventure.
Outer Wilds: Echoes of the Eye
A mysterious satellite photo uncovers the solar system's deepest secret in this Outer Wilds DLC.
Kinophobia
Explore a haunted movie studio to crack a macabre text-based mystery.
The Talos Principle 2
Robots rebuild human civilization in this philosophical first-person puzzler.
Riven (2024)
Solve the puzzling contraptions of Riven, a mysterious world on the verge of ruin.
The House Dreams Along With Them
Explore a secluded house through lucid dreams and unconventional puzzles.

Join our newsletter

Get a free thinky game to play and discuss, plus the latest thinky news and reviews, directly to your inbox every 2 weeks!