Games similar to Call of the Elder Gods

Enjoyed Call of the Elder Gods and looking for something fun to play next?

Our thinky games database has lots of hand-curated, detailed information about every game, so we're able to make great recommendations for other games you might enjoy. This includes other first-person, puzzle, and adventure games, more titles from Out of the Blue Games, and other games with narrative.

Take a look at some of the most similar games below.

Call of the Sea
Discover arcane knowledge on a remote South Pacific island.
Dimhaven - The Lost Source
Camera in hand, uncover the mysteries of Dimhaven island through first-person adventure puzzles.
Outer Wilds
Explore a solar system and unravel its mysteries.
Quern - Undying Thoughts
Uncover the secrets of Quern, solving contraption puzzles in this first-person puzzle adventure.
The Séance of Blake Manor
Investigate the disappearance of an aspirant occultist in a sinister hotel.
Mystery of the Malign
Untangle the threads behind a murder attempt at an eerie museum.
Blue Prince
Search for Room 46 in a mysterious manor where the rooms are different each time you enter.
Return of the Obra Dinn
A grisly detective mystery aboard a ghost, merchant ship.
We Were Here Forever
You awaken, trapped within Castle Rock, to continue the co-op saga of the We Were Here series.
We Were Here Together
Continuing co-op series We Were Here, venture into the freezing antarctic to rescue your fellow explorers.
Tri: Of Friendship and Madness
Conjure gravity-defying triangular platforms to explore every corner of the Odd Gods' world.
Looking For Fael
Escape from your own apartment, transformed into a surreal labyrinth.
We Were Here Too
In the second entry of the We Were Here franchise, work together to uncover the grim fate of Castle Rock.
Professor Layton and the New World of Steam
A ghost incident in Steam Bison begins a new riddle-filled adventure for the puzzle-solving duo.
Neyyah
Explore a bizarre island full of mysterious machinery and learn about its previous inhabitants.
Portal 2
Portal returns with an expansive story, new mechanics, and a co-op mode.
Myst (2021)
A genre-defining adventure across enigmatic worlds.
Obduction
Explore a broken alien landscape in this first-person adventure from the creators of Myst.
Firmament
Uncover the mysteries of the 3 Realms in this seemingly abandoned world.
We Were Here
Solve co-op puzzles in an abandoned castle with only walkie-talkies to communicate.
Outer Wilds: Echoes of the Eye
A mysterious satellite photo uncovers the solar system's deepest secret in this Outer Wilds DLC.
Once Glorious Artahk
Solve murals and mysteries among the ruins of a bygone city.
Professor Layton and the Miracle Mask
Help the puzzle-solving team expose the villainous Masked Gentleman.
Professor Layton and the Azran Legacy
Tackle an eclectic collection of puzzles as you go after the artifacts of a mythical civilization.
Professor Layton and the Last Specter
Meet young Luke and investigate a paranormal mystery through a new collection of brain teasers.
Supraland
A puzzle metroidvania set in a toy, miniature world.
Riven (2024)
Solve the puzzling contraptions of Riven, a mysterious world on the verge of ruin.
Spider and Web
Retrace the actions of a captured spy to a menacing interrogator.
La-Mulana
Put on your adventurer's hat and dive into a dangerous maze of cryptic secrets.
Supraworld
Explore an outsized playroom filled to the brim with secrets.

Join our newsletter

Get a free thinky game to play and discuss, plus the latest thinky news and reviews, directly to your inbox every 2 weeks!